News & Insights

The EU results are in: were we right to predict a shift to the right?

It is too early to estimate the likely priorities and direction for EU policy in the 2024-2029 mandate. We can, however, expect increasing unpredictability from a larger number of eurosceptic, right-wing populists and potential splits in the unity of the EPP, accompanied by a weakened centre-left

BRUSSELS – The answer is yes and no.

Between Thursday 6 and Sunday 9 June, almost 200 million European citizens turned out to vote for 720 MEPs to sit in the European Parliament for the next five years. So what happened?

Reading the European press in the days following the election you would be forgiven for thinking that far-right parties had swept the board, that the polling had rung true and the European Union will be heading in a new and unfamiliar direction. The reality is that while right of centre parties picked up votes and seats, and there were certainly some very dramatic national results, the pro-European centre retained its majority.

In France, Marine Le Pen’s Rassemblement National (RN) won more than 30% of the votes, catalysing President Macron’s gamble to dissolve the French parliament and call elections for the end of this month. In Germany, the three parties of the ruling coalition (Chancellor Scholz’s SPD, the Greens and the FDP) came in third, fourth and sixth place respectively.

And yet, looking at the bigger picture across all 27 member states, the pro-European centre came out stronger than expected. Ursula von der Leyen’s centre-right EPP group increased its share of the vote and number of seats meaning, with the help of negotiation and some EU courting, she is likely to secure a second term as President of the European Commision.

Moreover, the traditional pro-European centrist alliance – EPP, S&D and Renew – retains just over 400 of the 720 Parliament seats, pointing to more policy continuity – in particular for von der Leyen’s flagship Green Deal, previously thought to be threatened – as well as less radical change in the new Parliament’s committees and structures than some commentators had anticipated.

However, the success of far-right parties in the ‘oldest’ member states such as France, Austria, Belgium, Germany, and The Netherlands cannot be dismissed and in that regard the winds have changed.

Whilst voters cast their ballots based on national or even local issues and these results can be seen as judgement on the popularity of Europe’s diverse national governments, the surge in popularity for right-wing popular politicians and parties cannot be ignored, and is a Europe-wide phenomenon.

 

But does this mean a change in policy direction?

Simply put – and not the answer we all want – It is too early to make definitive statements about the likely priorities and direction for EU policy in the 2024-2029 mandate. We can, however, expect increasing unpredictability from a larger number of eurosceptic, right-wing populists and potential splits in the unity of the EPP, accompanied by a weakened centre-left.

The Socialists and Greens are weakened, but equally the new right-wing MEPs will not necessarily act as a united force, given that they are unlikely to be able to organise themselves into a single political group. Both the European Conservatives and Reformists (ECR) and Identity and Democracy (ID) groups have increased their numbers.

Furthermore, if some EPP MEPs respond to the threat from the right by embracing more protectionist or populist policies, that may split the centre-right faction. As this is von der Leyen’s political group, she may find herself pulled in opposite directions.

More generally, a shift to the right in Parliament may also not necessarily be more pro-business, as protectionist, populist and nationalist agendas are likely to be prominent. And finally, of course, new policy will ultimately depend on the makeup of the new Commission. However, with von der Leyen the most likely candidate for Commission President, we can expect continuity in the Green Deal, with some priority shifts towards more urgent policy issues including notably EU defence and competitiveness as she placates her new alliance of MEPs.

Crucially, companies and organisations will have to decide how to approach engagement with the new Parliament. In previous years many chose to bypass politicians representing far-right parties but, with so many now in the new Parliament and potentially taking influential roles, it will be important to consider engagement with MEPs from these groups.

Contact

John Duhig, Partner at BOLDT: [email protected]